Optimising Façade Designs for Wind Loads

By July 01 , 2016

A façade typically represents 30 per cent of the total development cost. The taller and more complex the building becomes, the figures escalate. A key component of the cost is the thickness of glass, framing members and size of brackets – all which are largely dictated by the wind loads that the building is subjected to. I

In today’s world, tall buildings dominate the skyline thus defining the prosperity of any modern city. Over the last two decades, the number of tall buildings over 200m in height has increased by 352 per cent (Reference CTBHU Research) and is growing. An estimate shows that Asia alone accounts
for more 70 per cent of high buildings, which are above +200 m, globally.

With early involvement of façade engineering expertise, savings can be made through coordination of the structural design. Added value can be achieved with a façade design that is sympathetic to the local environment, that meets the performance parameters andmaximises a developments overall value.

Advanced engineering methods should be considered when optimising the façade design for wind loads. These include wind tunnel testing and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). The application and benefits of these methods are discussed in the context of two case studies: Port Baku Towers 2 in Azerbaijan and Mitre Square in London.

The Challenge

Wind pressure assessment is a key parameter when designing the façade. The accurate prediction of wind pressure becomes more critical while dealing with complex and high rise structures. It not only helps to mitigate wind induced damages, such as broken glass and failure of the façade structure or components, but also directly correlates to the initial high capital cost of the façade.

Creechurch PlaceCreechurch Place – optimising the façade design for wind loads

Accurate prediction of wind pressures are essential at an early stage of a development to ensure the feasibility of a façade design in terms of safety and economics. While dealing with complex and tall buildings, it is always recommended to use a scaled wind tunnel test as results have shown that the wind loads calculated based on codes can be too conservativecompared to wind tunnel tests and potentially lead to higher façade costs.

In case of tall and complex buildings, CFD wind simulations should be considered in the earlier stages to assess the risk associated with the desired architectural intent. It provides façade engineers sufficient information to calculate the façade system structure based on localised pressures rather than the overall pressure.

The movements and deformations that need to be considered while designing the façade include differential column shortening, lateral story drift, building racking, slab and beam edge deflections and building vibrations.

Strong collaboration between the façade engineer and the structural engineer becomes a priority to ensure the façade performs as intended. A lack of coordination can have significant impact; failure modes may include panel fallout, connection failure, excessive rotation of glass within the framing, and irregular joints.

To accommodate high interstory drift due to high wind and seismic loads, customisation of the façade system may be required in some cases with wider vertical joints and stiffer profiles. These considerations are explored further in the case studies that follow.

Case Study 1
Port Baku Tower 2

#Fig.1: Port Baku Tower 2
#

The original development comprised of 2 towers (240m and 100m), a 4 storey podium with shopping facilities and multi storey underground car park. The complex façade geometry mainly comprises of a curved unitised curtain wall along the south face resulting in a spectacular skylight over the main entrance area. In all there were 12 different façade typologies that where defined and designed accordingly.

Considering the complex geometry, there were initial challenges involved in determining the wind loads for the façade elements. This was resolved by conducting wind tunnel testing on a scaled model of the development. Pressures were determined for each façade elevation. The results were quite challenging as wind pressures were shown to be in excess of 4.0 kPa at podium levels and up to -7.5 kPa for the main tower areas.

These high magnitude wind pressures resulted in bespoke design of façade system elements. A unitised façade system was developed to overcome problems associated with the installation of a stick system and reduce on-site installation time.

Coordination at an early stage with the structural consultant resulted in an agreement on the allowable building movements, deflection and structural tolerances. Slab edge deflections for the structure where limited to 1.5mm/1m length for dead load to reduce any potential racking façade panel units. The vertical and horizontal joint widths of the units as well as restraints were designed to accommodate all the building movements and prevent any potential rotation of panels.

#

The designed joints between the units were also assessed taking into consideration the worst case scenario to accommodate the movement resulting from the inter-storey drift, considering the limit of H/300 to the peak high magnitude wind load/ Seismic loads.

Challenges also involved designing unique façade brackets due to the complex geometry and high wind loads. The special bracket was designed to safely transfer the loads back to the main structure without compromising the structural integrity of the façade system.

Peak Net & Differential Facades/Cladding Negative Pressures

#

Notes:

  1. All values presented are in kPa
  2. All pressures stated are working pressures and need to be applied in conjuction with the appropriate code-compliant wind loading combination factors.
  3. For architectural features of the proposed development, where both sides of surfaces are exposed to the wind such as parapets, canopies and roofs, cladding pressure are assessed as peak differential pressures (resulting net wind force. All other areas are assessed as peak net pressures, which incorporated internal pressures
  4. Geometries presented in red indicates the louvers on the proposed development
  5. Geometries presented are in Full scale measurements in units of mm
#Fig.2: Wind Tunnel test model (above) Test Results (below)
#Fig.4: Rotation of units due to slab edge deflction with and without horizontal restraints and horizontal racking.

QUICK FACTS

Project: Port Baku Tower 2
Location: Baku, Azerbaijan
Architect: Chapman Taylor Architects
Façade Types: Curved Unitised Façade Solid Rainscreen Cladding Louvered Façade Storefront Façade Podium Terrace Standing Seam Roofing System Skylight
Status: Re-design

Case Study 2
Creechurch Place

Creechurch Place is a 96 m tall office building. The façade mainly comprises of double skin curtain wall, which incorporates automated blind system within the cavity and inner operable leaf for cleaning and maintenance access. There were 15 different façade typologies which have been defined and designed accordingly.

#Creechurch Place

CFD analysis has been used by the façade engineering team to determine initial cladding loads and enable more detailed pressure maps to the established elevations compared to code calculations.

The units have been designed by means of temperature analysis in the ventilated cavity, which comprised of air intake through the transom joint and of air outlet staggered through perforated parts in the mullions creating hidden vents. This design allowed for a reduction in external pressures by ventilation (pressure equalised system) and significantly reducing potential water ingress.

#

Even though every unit has been fitted with an operable full height window, the air leakage could be reduced to a very low ratio, way below the usual requirements. This could be achieved using standard window components comprising triple gaskets with multi-lock ironmongery in combination with the external laminated glass which reduced the stress on the inner construction.

Early involvement of specialised high rise façade engineering can not only significantly reduce the overall façade investment, through identifying the need for and carrying out methods such as wind tunnel testing and / or Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), but can also deliver considerable benefits in terms of performance and appearance. Ultimately leading to a conducive environment for its occupants and adding value to the overall scheme.

QUICK FACTS

Project: Creechurch Place
Location: London, UK
Architect: Sheppard Robson Architects
Façade Types: Unitised Façade, double Skin with Vertical Fins Long Span Double Height Glazing Louvered Façade Link Bridge Structurally Bonded Double Glazing
Status: under Construction

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *